| | | |
|---|
| | Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike
Vanya and his adopted sister, Sonia, live a quiet life in the Pennsylvania farmhouse where they grew up. When their sister, Masha and her boy toy, Spike, come to visit one weekend their whole lives will be upended in hilarious fashion. | Buy tickets |
| | I Bet Your Life
When soap opera writer Matthew Stoddard can’t convince his agent/best friend Greg that his new screenplay premise is believable—a terminal man hires a hit man to kill him, then learns his diagnosis was wrong—he decides to prove it. Matt stages a country dinner party with a “hit man” targeting a “dying” Greg. The catch: there’s a real hit man in the room, and nobody knows who it is. With the clock ticking, their secretary Stacy caught in the middle, and every twist landing with a genuine jolt, I Bet Your Life asks: who’s the con, and who’s the mark? | Buy tickets |
| | The Best Christmas Pageant Ever
Our 2026 Holiday Show
In this hilarious Christmas classic, a couple struggling to put on a church Christmas pageant is faced with casting the Herdman kids--probably the most inventively awful kids in history. You won't believe the mayhem - and the fun - when the Herdmans collide with the Christmas story head-on! This delightful comedy is adapted from the best-selling Young Adult book and has become a holiday tradition here at Barley Sheaf. With an amazing cast of all ages that is sure to spread holiday cheer, it really is the Best Christmas Pageant Ever!
| Buy tickets |
| | Baby
What could be more thrilling, more terrifying, or more life-changing than the news that a baby is on the way? Baby follows three couples at very different stages of life — college students barely figuring out who they are, thirty-somethings pouring everything they have into the dream of starting a family, and empty-nesters who thought they were finally done — all brought together by the most universal of surprises. By turns laugh-out-loud funny and quietly devastating, this deeply human musical celebrates the messy, miraculous ways a new life can upend everything you thought you knew about yourself, your relationship, and what comes next. | Buy tickets |
| | Storyspinners
Stories make us human, but in this play, stories can make us many other things. The storyspinners work together to conjure up new worlds, but they don’t always agree on the path the stories will take. Their arguments lead to laughter, but when they are at their best, working as one, the result is sheer magic. Ed Bernstein and Melissa Shaner use heightened “fairy tale” language and quickfire dialogue, physical comedy, and poignant lyricism, to bring out the power of storytelling to link past and future, fantasy and reality, individuals and communities. | Buy tickets |
| | Snapshots: A Musical Scrapbook
A new musical featuring songs from Stephen Schwartz, Snapshots: A Musical Scrapbook is a touching and authentic look into how we fall in love and the power of trusting our hearts and memories. Sue has her bags packed and the resolution to leave her husband, Dan, after decades of their lives entwined. Finding herself in their dusty, suburban attic for a final goodbye, Sue is startled when Dan arrives home early. Surrounded by memories and phantoms of their former selves, Sue and Dan embark on a journey to the past, rediscovering the love that remained hidden in a lifetime of Snapshots. | Buy tickets |